MG1 for new shooters?

[IPshooter]

I'm working with a couple of younger shooters who want to step up from the IZH46 to a better AP. And, they probably can't go all the way to a new or slightly used 162EI or a LP10.

Here's the question: is the MG1 a reasonable solution for them?

I've read through some older posts and seen where there were some apparent early quality/production issues. And, I surely do not want to steer these kids in the wrong direction. Have these issues been resolved?

Any comments from experienced MG1 owners would be appreciated.

Thanks,

Stan

[nvalcik]

I have a GP1 (Gehmann's version of the MG1) and I like it so far. I bought a MG1 short cylinder and this for me helps immensely. I have had no problems whatsoever and I have been very satisfied with the air pistol. In addition I felt the GP1 was reasonably priced compared to the rest of the ones I looked at for the same type of high end air pistol. I think for Juniors I would see about getting the GP1 with the MG1 short cylinders.

[IPshooter]

I have a GP1 (Gehmann's version of the MG1) and I like it so far. I bought a MG1 short cylinder and this for me helps immensely. I have had no problems whatsoever and I have been very satisfied with the air pistol. In addition I felt the GP1 was reasonably priced compared to the rest of the ones I looked at for the same type of high end air pistol. I think for Juniors I would see about getting the GP1 with the MG1 short cylinders.

Thank you for your reply.

Would you rate the GP1 to be on the same level as a Morini or Steyr?

I like your suggestion about the short cylinder for Juniors.

BTW, that solution also helps Seniors who seem to be afflicted with all kinds of problems which get in the way of shooting.

Stan

[jipe]

If it is to buy an additional short cylinder, why not go for a Steyr LP2 short ? It should more or less end up at the same price.

[william]

You will give up nothing with MG1 even compared to a Steyr or Morini, unless you happen to have an electric trigger fetish.

If you're in the US, how about Benelli Kite Young (their term for short). Larry Carter sell them brand spankin' new for under $1000.

http://www.larrysguns.com/Products/Bene ... istol.aspx

Disclosure: I have no financial interest in either Benelli or Larry Carter's shop.

[Mark Briggs]

I've recently had a chance to shoot an MG-1E, and for those who DO have an electronic trigger fetish, well, this trigger will really make you happy. The fit/finish of the pistol is just as good as a Steyr, and frankly makes the Morini look somewhat low-quality. The compensator works very well. Although I didn't get an opportunity to shoot a lot of shots I was very impressed with the few I did take. If I had to choose over again I might just be tempted by the MG-1E.

[IPshooter]

You will give up nothing with MG1 even compared to a Steyr or Morini, unless you happen to have an electric trigger fetish.

If you're in the US, how about Benelli Kite Young (their term for short). Larry Carter sell them brand spankin' new for under $1000.

http://www.larrysguns.com/Products/Bene ... istol.aspx

Disclosure: I have no financial interest in either Benelli or Larry Carter's shop.

William,

Thanks for the tip on the Benelli. I have zero experience with them.

How would you compare the Benelli to a Morini or a Steyr?

Stan

[IPshooter]

I've recently had a chance to shoot an MG-1E, and for those who DO have an electronic trigger fetish, well, this trigger will really make you happy. The fit/finish of the pistol is just as good as a Steyr, and frankly makes the Morini look somewhat low-quality. The compensator works very well. Although I didn't get an opportunity to shoot a lot of shots I was very impressed with the few I did take. If I had to choose over again I might just be tempted by the MG-1E.

Mark,

Thanks for the info about the MG-1E. This is another one I have no experience with, and it's helpful to hear from someone who knows something about it.

One of the kids I'm working with might consider the MG-1E. He really liked the Morini 162 EI trigger when he gave it a try and preferred it over the Steyr.

Stan

[Brian James]

IPShooter,

I am the owner of hte MG1E Mark refers to in his post. I own a Morini 162ie short and the MG1e - there is a significant wieght/balance difference between the Morini short and MG1e. The MG1 has a lot more weight forward and is a long version.

I would try to see which pistol suites the shooter best, and if there is a possibility the shooter will be out of the sport in a year or so, I would consider the pistol with the highest resale value.

Brian

[IPshooter]

IPShooter,

I am the owner of hte MG1E Mark refers to in his post. I own a Morini 162ie short and the MG1e - there is a significant wieght/balance difference between the Morini short and MG1e. The MG1 has a lot more weight forward and is a long version.

I would try to see which pistol suites the shooter best, and if there is a possibility the shooter will be out of the sport in a year or so, I would consider the pistol with the highest resale value.

Brian

Brian and everyone,

Thanks for the feedback.

Stan

[nvalcik]

IPShooter,

I went with a short cylinder due to having problems with my elbow. The extra weight that the short cylinder saves makes a big difference to me in any case. I tried the Steyr and the Morini, but I liked the MG1 the best out of the three.

[IPshooter]

IPShooter,

I went with a short cylinder due to having problems with my elbow. The extra weight that the short cylinder saves makes a big difference to me in any case. I tried the Steyr and the Morini, but I liked the MG1 the best out of the three.

I, too, am trying to extend my shooting career with a short cylinder. Not sure, yet, if it's going to make a real difference.

Since you picked the MG1 over the Steyr and the Morini, can you tell me what were the deciding factors for you?

Thanks,

Stan

[nvalcik]

I think you will be pleasantly surprised how much lighter a short cylinder will make your air pistol.