Page 1 of 1

Chen Ying's pistol

Posted: Wed Aug 13, 2008 10:18 pm
by Fortitudo Dei
Here's an image of Chen Ying on her way to winning Gold in 25m Pistol at the Beijing Olympics. Can anyone identify what her pistol is?

Posted: Wed Aug 13, 2008 10:44 pm
by Bill Poole
i thought it looked like a Hammerli 208

if its not, let me know I posted that on another forum I'd need to correct

maybe itsa model 41

what was Gundegmaa Otryad using? the magazine loaded into the pistol from the TOP (watch the finals video)

Poole

Posted: Wed Aug 13, 2008 11:30 pm
by Dogchaser
Not a 208 and not a 41.

I have no idea. I blew it up and the trigger guard is square.

Posted: Wed Aug 13, 2008 11:33 pm
by Spencer
if it was a 208 I think the slide would soon make short work of the top rear of that grip

Spencer

Posted: Thu Aug 14, 2008 12:02 am
by AAlex
Most likely a replica of one of the Khaidurov prototypes.

Reasons for my guess:
1) Kinda looks like one (XP-30 ?)
2) Clearly not anything that's on sale.
3) If "made to order" - Khaidurov design is an obvious choice.

Could be a Chinese design built from scratch (since they now use their own ammo too, so it is not too far-fetched); However, that is not Chinese modus operandi, if you know what I mean.

Posted: Thu Aug 14, 2008 12:10 am
by Fortitudo Dei
I've just found another photo of it from when she was at the ISSF World Cup shoot in Munich last year. This image is much clearer - but I'm none the wiser...

Posted: Thu Aug 14, 2008 12:14 am
by j-team
It's a chinese pistol. I used to know the model number but have forgotten.

There is at least one here in New Zealand as I used to know the guy that was the owner. Has since been sold and I don't know who has it now.

I think that they had a little lever (like an air pistol) which would re-cock the hammer without having to rack the slide.

If it is the one I think they have been around since about the late 1980s.

Posted: Thu Aug 14, 2008 12:53 am
by LukeP
Bill Poole wrote: what was Gundegmaa Otryad using? the magazine loaded into the pistol from the TOP (watch the finals video)
2nd Gundegmaa OTRYAD Walther SSP
Image

3rd Munkhbayar DORJSUREN Walther SSP
More pics http://www.issfnews.com/default.aspx?mo ... =11&inst=0

Posted: Thu Aug 14, 2008 8:07 am
by jipe
LukeP wrote:
Bill Poole wrote: what was Gundegmaa Otryad using? the magazine loaded into the pistol from the TOP (watch the finals video)
2nd Gundegmaa OTRYAD Walther SSP
Image

3rd Munkhbayar DORJSUREN Walther SSP
More pics http://www.issfnews.com/default.aspx?mo ... =11&inst=0
I have been looking the WC finals on ISSF tv and it seems to me that its the first time that there is an SSP in a world event final.

If I remember well, till now Gundegmaa OTRYAD was using a FWB AW93.

Posted: Thu Aug 14, 2008 9:01 am
by rrpc
On the subject of Otryad, does anyone know what the reason was that she put up her hand in the 3rd or 4th series.

Normally you'd expect it to be a malfunction, but the Range Officer didn't check her pistol which is the normal procedure.

Posted: Thu Aug 14, 2008 10:04 am
by David Levene
rrpc wrote:On the subject of Otryad, does anyone know what the reason was that she put up her hand in the 3rd or 4th series.

Normally you'd expect it to be a malfunction, but the Range Officer didn't check her pistol which is the normal procedure.
He did check her pistol. Presumably he saw that the slide was half open (or some other visible malfunction) so he would not need to touch the pistol.

The strange thing was that her malfunction was on the 2nd shot but she didn't raise her hand until the others had fired their 4th shots (could have been 3rd but I don't think so). She also rested her pistol on the bench (not permitted). That wasn't such a grave error with an SSP but could have covered up an incorrect magazine insertion on a GSP/SP20/SP1 etc.

Having seen it on TV I am sure there was no intention to cheat but it was a technical breach of at least 2 rules. She has probably carried out the correct procedure thousands of times; my guess is that the occasion addled her brain.

Posted: Thu Aug 14, 2008 8:39 pm
by ColinC
Chen's pistol is not just an IZH-35M with Morini grips is it?

Posted: Fri Aug 15, 2008 3:54 am
by rrpc
David Levene wrote: He did check her pistol. Presumably he saw that the slide was half open (or some other visible malfunction) so he would not need to touch the pistol.

The strange thing was that her malfunction was on the 2nd shot but she didn't raise her hand until the others had fired their 4th shots (could have been 3rd but I don't think so). She also rested her pistol on the bench (not permitted). That wasn't such a grave error with an SSP but could have covered up an incorrect magazine insertion on a GSP/SP20/SP1 etc.

Having seen it on TV I am sure there was no intention to cheat but it was a technical breach of at least 2 rules. She has probably carried out the correct procedure thousands of times; my guess is that the occasion addled her brain.
Yes she took quite a long time to signal the malfunction. Having watched it again I could see where she attempted the second shot which I hadn't seen before. And yes the pistol should remain pointing down range.

Posted: Fri Aug 15, 2008 3:58 am
by rrpc
ColinC wrote:Chen's pistol is not just an IZH-35M with Morini grips is it?
I don't think so. The back sight f the IZH is a good deal deeper on the IZH then the one on Chen's pistol. Here's a side view of the IZH:

Image

As you can see there are a good few differences.

Posted: Fri Aug 15, 2008 4:37 am
by j-team
ColinC wrote:Chen's pistol is not just an IZH-35M with Morini grips is it?
It's a Chinese produced pistol. Read my previous post!

Posted: Fri Aug 15, 2008 4:46 am
by rrpc
Back to Otryad again. She must be sponsored by someone else because the Walther name is covered up everywhere it appears on her SSP.

Feinwerkbau?

Posted: Fri Aug 15, 2008 8:06 am
by David Levene
rrpc wrote:Back to Otryad again. She must be sponsored by someone else because the Walther name is covered up everywhere it appears on her SSP.
That would probably be because of rule 51 of the Olympic Charter and its byelaws, mainly 1.1 "The identification of the manufacturer shall not appear more than once per item of clothing and equipment." and 8 "The word "identification" means the normal display of the name, designation, trademark, logo or any other distinctive sign of the manufacturer of the item, appearing not more than once per item."